The Commerce Report

Head to head

Klaviyo vs Shopify Email: when to switch

Stay on Shopify Email while you send a newsletter and a basic abandoned-cart message. Move to Klaviyo when you want flows that branch on purchase history and segments built from behaviour. The switch pays off when repeat purchases are a meaningful share of revenue.

What each one is

Shopify Email, now part of Shopify Messaging, lives inside the Shopify admin. It sends campaigns from your product data and supports a set of standard automations. The first 10,000 emails each month are free and extra sends are charged per thousand, so it costs little to start.

Klaviyo is a separate platform that syncs your full order and browsing history, then lets you build segments and multi-step flows on top of it.

Shopify Email and Klaviyo
Shopify EmailKlaviyo
Where it livesInside the Shopify adminA separate platform that syncs your store data
Free allowance10,000 emails a month250 active profiles and 500 emails a month
How the price scalesBy emails sentBy active profiles
SMSYes, within Shopify MessagingYes, as an add-on

Signs you have outgrown Shopify Email

  • You want a different message for first-time and repeat buyers.
  • You want to stop emailing people who have not opened in months.
  • You want a win-back sequence timed to how often customers reorder.
  • You want email and SMS coordinated so a customer does not get both at once.

The cost question

Klaviyo charges by active profiles, meaning every contact you are able to market to, so the bill grows with your list whether or not those profiles buy. Clean the list before you migrate and you start on a lower tier.

See Klaviyo pricing

Why this matters to your ad spend

Email is where the cost of an acquired customer gets paid back. A store with working post-purchase and win-back flows can afford a higher cost per first order than one without, which changes what you can bid.

Over the counter

What does Shopify Email actually cost?

The first 10,000 emails each calendar month are free on paid Shopify plans, then $1 per 1,000 up to 300,000. Abandoned-checkout automations do not count against the free allowance.

What counts as an active profile in Klaviyo?

Any contact you are able to market to. The bill tracks the size of that list whether or not those profiles buy, which is why cleaning the list before migrating changes the tier you land on.

Does Shopify Email send SMS now?

Yes. It is part of Shopify Messaging, which sends email, SMS and WhatsApp campaigns from the Shopify admin.

When is the switch worth doing?

When repeat purchases are a meaningful share of revenue and you want flows that branch on what someone has already bought, rather than one message to everyone.

What we read, and when

Checked November 15, 2026. These pages change without notice, so the source wins over anything here.

By Thomas Ho, who runs paid acquisition and conversion tracking for ecommerce and lead-generation businesses.

First published November 15, 2026. Prices and features re-checked November 15, 2026.

Thomas HoPerformance marketing consultant

  • 4+ yearsrunning paid campaigns
  • $100k a monthlargest budget managed
  • 4 ad platformsMeta, Google, TikTok, LinkedIn
  • Server-sideGA4, Tag Manager, conversion APIs
More about the author